Lesson 3: Choosing Mixers and Balancing Flavor

A great drink is a balancing act. Too much of one thing and it tastes like cough syrup, lemonade, or lighter fluid. This lesson gives you the five dials every drink has, and how to turn them.

The five dials of every drink

DialWhere it comes fromWhat it does
StrongThe spiritBackbone and warmth
SweetSimple syrup, liqueurs, juices, sodasSoftens the alcohol and rounds things out
SourLemon or lime juiceBrightens and keeps sweetness from getting cloying
BitterBitters, tonic, coffee, some liqueursAdds depth, like salt and pepper for drinks
WaterMelting ice, soda, juiceTames the burn and opens up flavor

A ratio worth memorizing

Many classic drinks follow the sour pattern: 2 parts spirit, 3/4 part sour, 3/4 part sweet. Shake it with ice and you have a Daiquiri (rum, lime, sugar), a Whiskey Sour (whiskey, lemon, sugar), or a basic Lemon Drop (vodka, lemon, sugar). Swap the sweetener for an orange liqueur and you are well on the way to a Margarita or a Sidecar.

Fixing a drink that tastes off

Taste before you pour for guests. Dip a straw in, cap the top with your finger, and sip. Then adjust in small steps, about 1/4 oz at a time.

If it tastes…Try this
Too sweetAdd 1/4 oz lemon or lime juice, or a dash of bitters
Too sourAdd 1/4 oz simple syrup
Too strong or “hot”Shake a few seconds longer, add a splash of soda, or serve over more ice
Watery or thinUse colder, fresher ice, shake for less time, or cut back on the mixer
Flat or boringA dash of bitters, a squeeze of citrus, or a twist of peel over the top

Two small habits, big difference

  • Squeeze citrus fresh. Bottled lemon and lime juice taste dull and a bit metallic. Fresh juice is the single easiest upgrade. It keeps a day or two in the fridge.
  • Make your own simple syrup. Stir equal parts sugar and hot water until dissolved, cool, and refrigerate. It keeps about a month. That is the whole recipe.

For a deeper look at sodas, juices, syrups, and bitters, visit Mixers and Mixing.